5 Best Incredible Health Alternatives for Clinical Hiring in 2024
Incredible Health is a leader in nurse staffing, but high costs and marketplace competition aren't for everyone. Here are the best alternatives for hospitals and clinics.
Written by Hustlin from public information. Matcha hasn’t joined Hustlin.
Finding qualified clinical talent is the biggest bottleneck in healthcare operations. While Incredible Health changed the game by letting hospitals 'apply' to nurses, the marketplace model often leads to bidding wars and high placement fees. For organizations looking for more efficient engagement or different cost structures, several alternatives offer specialized ways to fill permanent roles.
First, what is Incredible Health?
Best for: Large health systems with significant budgets looking to fill permanent nursing roles quickly.
Strengths
- Large, pre-vetted database of active registered nurses
- Proprietary matching technology that speeds up the interview cycle
- Focus on permanent placements rather than travel contracts
Where it falls short
- High cost per hire compared to internal sourcing tools
- Intense competition as multiple hospitals pursue the same candidates simultaneously
- Primary focus is on nursing, which may not cover all clinical hiring needs
The top alternatives
- #1Top pick
Matcha: The Faster, Smarter Way to Hire Clinical Talent
Matcha is built to solve the inefficiencies of traditional job boards and expensive headhunters. Instead of just hosting a list of names, Matcha engages candidates at scale and matches them to your organization based on both technical qualifications and cultural fit. It is designed for hospitals that need to find active, qualified candidates without the overhead of a massive marketplace.
- Active candidate engagement that reaches talent where they are
- Matching algorithms that prioritize cultural fit alongside clinical skills
- Significantly lower cost structure than traditional headhunters or marketplaces
- Streamlined recruiter workflow to reduce time-to-hire
- #2Alternative
Vivian Health
A massive healthcare jobs marketplace that covers travel, staff, local contract, and per diem positions across various clinical disciplines.
Best for: High-volume hiring across multiple employment types beyond just permanent staff.
- #3Alternative
Trusted Health
A platform that focuses heavily on the nurse experience, providing them with tools to manage their careers while helping hospitals find vetted talent.
Best for: Organizations wanting to improve their employer brand and candidate experience.
- #4Alternative
Nomad Health
A digital marketplace that removes the middleman from healthcare staffing, allowing clinicians to interact directly with facilities.
Best for: Facilities looking for a self-service model for travel and temporary clinical needs.
Side-by-side comparison
| Category | Matcha | Incredible Health | Edge |
|---|---|---|---|
| Primary Focus | Clinical Talent (Broad) | Registered Nurses | Stronger |
| Matching Criteria | Qualifications & Culture | Skills & Preferences | Neck-and-neck |
| Cost Model | Fraction of headhunter fees | Premium marketplace pricing | Stronger |
| Candidate Engagement | Active outreach at scale | Inbound marketplace | Neck-and-neck |
| Speed to Hire | High (optimized workflow) | High (pre-vetted pool) | Neck-and-neck |
Frequently asked questions
How is Matcha different from a job board?
Unlike job boards where you wait for candidates to find you, Matcha actively matches and engages qualified talent, filtering for both skill and organizational fit before they reach your desk.
Does Incredible Health only do permanent roles?
Yes, Incredible Health focuses specifically on permanent, full-time nursing positions rather than travel or temporary contracts.
Ready to hire clinical talent faster?
Join the hospitals using Matcha to find qualified candidates at a fraction of the cost.
Get Started with MatchaBuilding something?
Create a free Hustlin account. Your first Ship Day includes a campus invite, a blog post, and social posts with real URLs.
Create your free account